What's on your Holy Grail/Must Try list?

[sigsauer]

dunhill cabinetta

[Pole Lock]

Opus BBMF.  Opus have really grown on me over the years.  Plenty of opportunities to pick up a BBMF over the years, but, man, $75+ is spicy for a cigar.  Sooner or later I'll come across one in the right state of intoxication and make it mine.

[alwayslit]

Bahia Gold A

[Charles]

Cohiba Gran Reserva 

It's very strange to see a post from Fire Ant..RIP Toby..

[miamipadronsmoker]

[quote author=miamipadronsmoker link=topic=5471.msg29615#msg29615 date=1286755287]
Dunhill Malecon

[/quote]

Same

[J.B.]

Montecristo #2 from the 1980's.

[kingcohiba]

[quote author=J.B. link=topic=5471.msg207523#msg207523 date=1644936964]
Montecristo #2 from the 1980's.
[/quote]

I had one from the early 80s about 5 years ago. The monte 2 is a cigar I've tried and tried to love but have always found it to just not be my thing. Except for that one from the early 80s.

I might be able to help you out with that? I believe that he still has a decent amount of a box left.

[Seegar3]

Montecristo No.1 from the middle or early nineties.

Also, any R&J Celestiales Fino, before they were discontinued.

[2manycigars]

[quote author=J.B. link=topic=5471.msg207523#msg207523 date=1644936964]
Montecristo #2 from the 1980's.
[/quote]

Have smoked two.  IMO, and I've been doing this for 40+ years, the single most, existential cigars I've stuffed in my face.

[NeedaBehike]

OG fundie, Dunhill Mojito, Ramon Allones Estupendos.