RyJ Smoker, what gives?

[PeteRI]

Appears that you're selling cigars you were gifted. If that's the case, you've got some 'splainin' to do.

[RyJ Smoker]

This was immediately explained to Danilo.  It was a complete misunderstanding on his part and nothing of my nature.  Was worked out with him instantaneously.  I'd like to think people know me a lot better than to ever do something like this.

I'll PM him this thread to comment in himself, once his 7-day ban is lifted.


Jeffrey L.

[RyJ Smoker]

To further elaborate, I sent Danilo a picture of the sticks that are for sale, with all of my multiples of each stick for sale laid out below the ones that are for sale.  Sticks that I've acquired through purchasing and trading.

None of what he so graciously bombed me were in that pic.  Bombed sticks are in a seperate humidor and I took pictures of those as well, as they're all still accounted for.


Jeffrey L.

[Knuck42]

I certainly have no dog in this here race, but knowing Jeffery even as casually as I do, I'd find it hard to believe he'd do something like this.  He has far too much class.

[PeteRI]

If that's the case, I apologize.

[RyJ Smoker]

[quote author=PeteRI link=topic=8335.msg44607#msg44607 date=1300449333]
If that's the case, I apologize.
[/quote]

Accepted, however I don't feel an apology was necessary.  Although it hurt to see a topic like this questioning my ethics and brotherhood, that is what the 'Battle Zone' is here for.

Your friend and brother,


Jeffrey L.

[canadianbeaver]

OK, so etiquette question for you all.

I have changed my smoking habits from big cigars to smaller and we all do from time to time. Or we have an overflow in the humidor as I read in postings, whatever.

Does that mean that you cannot put cigars up and trade them because we are keeping track? No disrespect meant of course.

CB

[Starbuck]

[quote author=Knuck42 link=topic=8335.msg44606#msg44606 date=1300448737]
I certainly have no dog in this here race, but knowing Jeffery even as casually as I do, I'd find it hard to believe he'd do something like this.  He has far too much class.
[/quote]

:bigup:

Totally agree with this comment. Jeffery without a doubt is a top notch brother of the leaf. Simple misunderstanding is all. I'd vouch for Jeffery any day.

[Knuck42]

[quote]OK, so etiquette question for you all.

I have changed my smoking habits from big cigars to smaller and we all do from time to time. Or we have an overflow in the humidor as I read in postings, whatever.

Does that mean that you cannot put cigars up and trade them because we are keeping track? No disrespect meant of course.

CB[/quote]
Interesting question that I'm predicting will yield some rather interesting responses.  And with regard to disrespect, I would think that the fact that you're asking demonstrates your desire to avoid it, and I say bully for you!

This question has come up before on other boards that I frequent or have frequented in the past.  There were guys jumping up and down screaming, "Hey, if you don't like the cigars I gifted you, just PM me and I'll happily buy them back from you at FMV!"

At the same time other guys were shouting, "Once you give something away it's the recipient's to do with as they please!" 

Whos is right?  I guess that's a matter of opinion, and we all know what people say about those... 

[RyJ Smoker]

[quote author=Knuck42 link=topic=8335.msg44630#msg44630 date=1300460068]
Interesting question that I'm predicting will yield some rather interesting responses.  And with regard to disrespect, I would think that the fact that you're asking demonstrates your desire to avoid it, and I say bully for you!

This question has come up before on other boards that I frequent or have frequented in the past.  There were guys jumping up and down screaming, "Hey, if you don't like the cigars I gifted you, just PM me and I'll happily buy them back from you at FMV!"

At the same time other guys were shouting, "Once you give something away it's the recipient's to do with as they please!" 

Whos is right?  I guess that's a matter of opinion, and we all know what people say about those... 
[/quote]

This here needs a topic of its own.  Selling a gifted/bombed cigar is VERY poor ettiquette.


Jeffrey L.