Onlinehumidor.com

So what's your favorite excluding LE/RE cigars?

For me it's the H. Upmann #2.  With 7 years of age or more these are hard to beat for complexity, subtlety of flavor, and for me, all around enjoyment.

Dang Bill you picked a hard one. I had to go with a coin toss between the Monte and H upman. The BBF and Dip #2 are also very good. How about a choice of all of the above!

[quote]How about a choice of all of the above![/quote]
Kind of defeats the purpose Bubba!

I always return to the Monte #2, though I have been intrigued by the Uppman as of late. I just missed being able to purchase a phenominal box code from 2001. The search continues :).

Jim

08 Upmann #2's have been incredible...

For me its always been the VR Unicos.  I have yet to try the H Upmann, I must admit. And I've only had a couple Diplomaticos #2's. For me, the Unicos is rich and sweet, while not as strong as the BBF(which is a very, very, close second).  I like the monte #2's, but they are a bit lighter than I prefer.  Great poll.

I would have to go with a Monte #2.

My 07' BBF's are killer right now!

Love the flavor of a well aged Monte #2.

Here are my rankings during my recent testing:

BBF              8/10
Mon #2        9.1/10
H Up #2        9.2/10
VR Unicos      9.15/10
Part Ser P #2 9/10

You forgot to add Cohiba Piramides EL 06    9.3/10

Bart