Onlinehumidor.com

I personally love the Family Reserve 45 maduro. What is everyone's favorite Family Reserve?

Been loving the 46 for me.

I enjoy the 46th the most, as much as I hate big ring gauge cigars.

45 was GREAT, as well as the 46, but I'd have to go with the 80-Maduro.  That was/is an amazing cigar.  Didn't like the 40th much at all, the 44 is good, and the 85 was decent as well.  But I would have to say that they are all better than any of the '64s and '26s, except the No.9 '26 Maduro.  That is one AMAZING smoke.  80th, then probably the No. 9-Maduro/45th/46th tied.  As for the 40th - Maduro (not actually a maduro, but more of a darker sungrown), I'd prefer a Maduro '64 over those.  It just didn't do it for me for some reason, IMO.

not had them all myself but the 45th was a great cigar. the natural just as good as the maduro imo. there were 3-4 in the box that really were worth the price tag.

Of the three that I have smoked (all maduro), I'd rank them:

1.  45th
2.  85th
3.  46th

Its sad that they are not coming out with a new family reserve rather a donkey dick 654 (60 gauge) :(

[quote author=SRQCigarman link=topic=13656.msg75880#msg75880 date=1346192192]
Its sad that they are not coming out with a new family reserve rather a donkey dick 654 (60 gauge) :(
[/quote]

Almost spit out my coffee but I totally agree, I can't understand this bigger RG phenomena.

Let the donkey dicks run around 7 by 60, 6 by 60, 5 by 60, 7 by 70 and so on and so forth. NO ME GUSTA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

85th Nattie