Page 4 of 4
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2016 7:05 am
by Hutch
One of the criteria of undue hardship is loss of efficiency. An employee not on the job lowers the efficiency and production, hence is undue hardships. And IIANM, aren't those guidelines are for federal agencies ?
BTW....How long are we talking? An hour over an 8 hour shift...2 ?....45 minutes ?
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2016 1:01 pm
by Gee-Man
[quote author=Hutch link=topic=36529.msg155495#msg155495 date=1452668722]
One of the criteria of undue hardship is loss of efficiency. An employee not on the job lowers the efficiency and production, hence is undue hardships. And IIANM, aren't those guidelines are for federal agencies ?
BTW....How long are we talking? An hour over an 8 hour shift...2 ?....45 minutes ?
[/quote]
Cornering the market Hutch ????
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2016 8:47 pm
by Mynamesnotdan
Can we stop arguing about the technicalities/semantics and just go back to being racist? That's way simpler.
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2016 10:31 pm
by NASTY WAS TAKEN
I think a lot of you are under the impression that these former workers prayed 5x during work hours.
Muslims pray before sunrise, around noon, late afternoon, right after sunset and then once more right before retiring. Prayer takes no more than 5-10 minutes. So unless this company has them working long hours, the workers might pray at the work place 3 times tops. In fact, I'm willing to bet that it takes them longer to walk to that makeshift prayer area and back than the actual prayer recital.
Now from what that company's spokesman is saying, by allowing 11 or so workers to go pray at the same time would leave a whole sector unmanned; that's proof that the accommodation would create an undue hardship.
But what the lawyer is saying is that the company, supervisor or whatever, told them go home if they wanted to pray, infringing upon their rights. That's the only legal argument they have...if it actually sticks.
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Wed Jan 13, 2016 11:06 pm
by Pole Lock
[quote author=Mynamesnotdan link=topic=36529.msg155519#msg155519 date=1452718026]
Can we stop arguing about the technicalities/semantics and just go back to being racist? That's way simpler.
[/quote]
Great idea! But let's not be bigoted towards Christianity cuz, um, that's the right fairy tale to believe in.
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2016 1:38 pm
by burnem
[quote author=Mynamesnotdan link=topic=36529.msg155519#msg155519 date=1452718026]
Can we stop arguing about the technicalities/semantics and just go back to being racist? That's way simpler.
[/quote]
Standby argument for when you run out of facts to present!
Re: MUSLIM PRAYERS DURING WORK HOURS
Posted: Sun Jan 17, 2016 5:34 pm
by Hutch
[quote author=NASTY WAS TAKEN link=topic=36529.msg155527#msg155527 date=1452724300]
I think a lot of you are under the impression that these former workers prayed 5x during work hours.
Muslims pray before sunrise, around noon, late afternoon, right after sunset and then once more right before retiring. Prayer takes no more than 5-10 minutes. So unless this company has them working long hours, the workers might pray at the work place 3 times tops. In fact, I'm willing to bet that it takes them longer to walk to that makeshift prayer area and back than the actual prayer recital.
Now from what that company's spokesman is saying, by allowing 11 or so workers to go pray at the same time would leave a whole sector unmanned; that's proof that the accommodation would create an undue hardship.
But what the lawyer is saying is that the company, supervisor or whatever, told them go home if they wanted to pray, infringing upon their rights. That's the only legal argument they have...if it actually sticks.
[/quote]
If these times and hours are accurate, I would be able to and willing to accommodate their customs. If it creates no hardship to my business, I see no reason to disallow it. I may apparently have been under a misconception as to how it would impact my business. If it doesn't affect me, I see no reason to give a shit :)