Onlinehumidor.com

[quote author=Ryan link=topic=23639.msg105688#msg105688 date=1388015783]
Elijah Craig 18 is great if you can find some.

Not a big bourbon guy, but 4 Roses is nice, Blantons, Woodford, and I had a single barrel/malt (?) Evan Williams 10 yr old bourbon I enjoyed.  All 50 and under save for the Elijah Craig 18.

I really like the Elijah Craig.  Have had Pappy 15 yr thanks to one generous fella here and it was indeed good, but the prices now are unreal.
[/quote]

I really like the Elijah Craig 12. Never tried anything older than their 12 year but I'd like to, and will one of these days.

I have two bottles of the parker's heritage down in the basement. Thinking of opening one soon to try. Mine is like 96 proof though. 7th edition.

I love elmer t lee, but it's not a wheater like pappy.

if you are looking for a similar experience to old van rip 10, weller  antique 107 proof for about $21 a bottle fits the bill. a steal IMHO.

larceny is a few bucks more and is good, but will go weller antique if available.

I like the black maple hill along with angels envy

I've enjoyed all of these:

Four Roses Single Barrel/Small Batch Limited Editions
Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2013
Rock Hill Farms
Blantons
Angels Envy
Jefferson 18 year

I enjoy reading the reviews on sourmashmanifesto.com and have enjoyed those he's highly recommended. 

So far some great suggestions.  Personally like just about all that were said and I have tried.  Only my favorite and should be around $40 wasn't mentioned yet.  Basil Haydens is well worth the money.  Also I just opened a bottle of evan williams single barrel the other day and that was excellent fir about $25.

Had some great 10-Summer old Rip Van Winkle today.

It was grrrrrreat.



Joel
CRA Member# 99977267

I would also see if you can find eagle rare 10 yo.  Should be 25-30 bucks and is great. 


Sent from my iPhone using [URL=http://tapatalk.com/m?id=1]Tapatalk[/URL]

Thank you all for the great suggestions. I picked up the woodford and some more Balvenie at Bevmo. I've had Blantons and enjoyed it but going to find the Elmer's/Craig too. Thanks again.

Don't buy old grand dad 101. Bought a 50ml of it and just now trying it. Bought it for nostalgic reasons....we finished a bottle of it in Healdsburg and chucked the empty bottle in the Russian River. It was my grand dad's whiskey. Evidently, he didn't have what I'd call a refined taste in bourbon. Lol

Would be fun to watch unappreciative buddies play quarters with it though.

Hope you enjoy your selections. I know that you'll like the Elijah Craig.  Let us know how you get on.

[quote author=Thunderdan11 link=topic=23639.msg105888#msg105888 date=1388291215]
I would also see if you can find eagle rare 10 yo.�  Should be 25-30 bucks and is great.�


Sent from my iPhone using [URL=http://tapatalk.com/m?id=1]Tapatalk[/URL]
[/quote]

+1 had some the other night and it was awesome

Sent from my KFTT using Tapatalk 2